Switching from full-list blasts to behaviorally segmented campaigns lifts every performance metric simultaneously for a newly licensed New York dispensary.
Email and SMSBehavioral Segmentation30-Day ImpactNew York
+38.5%
Revenue Per Message
+13.95%
Email Open Rate
+33%
Click-Through Rate
+15.7%
Conversion Rate
The Challenge
A newly licensed New York cannabis dispensary was sending identical email and SMS campaigns to their entire list, treating every customer the same regardless of purchase history. Open rates were modest, revenue per send was leaving money on the table, and there was no visibility into whether messaging was resonating with different buyer types. The objective: implement behavioral segmentation, run both approaches simultaneously, and measure the 30-day performance gap.
Baseline vs. Segmented Approach
Baseline Campaign
Sent to the full customer list with general messaging. No distinction between flower buyers, edibles shoppers, concentrate enthusiasts, or frequency segments. Every customer received the same campaign regardless of what they actually bought.
Segmented Campaign
Campaigns split by product category preference based on POS purchase history. Flower buyers received flower-focused campaigns. Edibles buyers received edibles campaigns. Each segment received messaging that matched their demonstrated buying behavior.
Before vs. After: All Four Key Metrics
Baseline (full list)
Segmented (by purchase behavior)
Open Rate
Baseline
27.59%
Segmented
31.44%
+13.95%
Click-Through Rate
Baseline
1.06%
Segmented
1.41%
+33.02%
Conversion Rate
Baseline
12.88%
Segmented
14.90%
+15.68%
Revenue Per Message
Baseline
$4.91
Segmented
$6.80
+38.50%
Key Takeaways
Segmentation lifts every metric at once. Open rate, CTR, conversion rate, and revenue per message all improved in the same 30-day window. This is the compounding effect of relevance: a message that matches buying behavior gets opened more, clicked more, and converted more.
Nearly 40% more revenue per send from the same list. The dispensary did not acquire new customers or increase send frequency. They changed who received what message. The result was $6.80 vs. $4.91 per send from the identical subscriber base.
Generic messaging has a measurable, avoidable cost. The $4.91 baseline revenue per send is what treating every customer identically costs in foregone revenue. Every unsegmented dispensary is leaving a similar gap on the table every single send.
The first 30 days can be transformational. This was a newly licensed operator. The baseline was not poor strategy. It was standard practice. The segmented result shows what is immediately possible when customer purchase data is actually used.
Ready to Segment Your List?
We build behaviorally segmented email and SMS programs for dispensaries across NY, NJ, and PA.